1. Consider the Source:
Whenever you read the results of psychology research in popular media sources, you should always consider the original source of the information. Studies published in professional psychology journals have gone through a rigorous examination process, starting with the original study conducted by a reputable researcher and generally backed by a educational institution, hospital or other organization. These journals are also peer-reviewed, which means that other psychologists skilled in research methods and statistics have investigated the research prior to publication.
2. Be Skeptical of Sensational or Shocking Claims:
When evaluating any type of scientific information, skepticism should always be the rule. Be especially wary of claims or findings that seem sensational or unrealistic. Remember that the goals of these popular media reports are to garner attention, sell issues and increase ratings. Reporters may focus on particular elements of a study, while ignoring other important information that is essential for understanding the results. Statements made by researchers may be used out of context in a way that dramatically overstates the original results of the study.
3. Evaluate the Research Methods:
In order to be a wise consumer of psychology, it is important to understand some of the basics of psychology research. Elements such as operational definitions, random sampling and research design are important for understanding the final results of a study. For example, a particular study may only look at specific individuals within a population or it may consider only a narrow definition of a particular topic. Both of these factors can play a role in what the findings mean to the general population and how the results can be applied to understanding psychological phenomena.
4. Remember That Anecdotes Do Not Equal Data:
Be wary of stories or reports that rely solely on anecdotal stories to back up their claims. Just because a small group of individuals have arrived at a similar conclusion does not mean that the population at large shares this view. Scientific research utilizes random sampling and other research methods to help ensure that the results of a study can be generalized to the rest of the population. Any report that relies on a “This is true for me, so it must be true for everyone else” justification should be viewed with skepticism.
5. Consider Who Funded the Research:
In evaluating psychological research, it is also important to consider the financial backers who supported the study. Funding can come from a variety of sources including government agencies, non-profit groups and large corporations.
6. Realize That Correlation Does Not Equal Causation:
Many popular reports of scientific research jump to conclusions and imply causal relationships between variables. A relationship between two variables, however, does not necessarily imply that changes in one cause changes in another. Never assume that there is a cause-and-effect relationship between two factors. Look for key phrases such as "researchers have found a connection", "research indicates a relationship between" and "there appears to be a link" to help identify correlational research.
Newspapers, magazines, books and online sources are full of information about the latest psychological research. In order to determine how trustworthy these reports are, it is important to know how to evaluate the stories you read. While looking up the original study is the best way to assess the information, you can also apply some basic scientific common sense. Be wary of sensationalized claims, watch out for false implications of causation and remember that skepticism is the rule when evaluating any scientific report.